Who needs individual health insurance?
Individual health insurance is for anyone who doesn’t have access to employer-sponsored or government-run health coverage. This includes people who are employed by a small business that doesn’t provide health benefits, people who are self-employed, and people who retire before they’re eligible for Medicare and have to get their own personal health coverage until they reach age 65.
How is individual health insurance different from employer-sponsored health insurance?
Now that the Affordable Care Act has been implemented, the differences between individual and employer-sponsored health coverage are much less significant than they once were.
Prior to 2014, individual health insurance was generally much less costly than group coverage in most states (although employers usually pay a significant portion of the premiums for group coverage, sometimes giving enrollees the impression that their coverage is much less expensive than it actually is). The reason for the significant price discrepancy pre-2014 was because individual plans were medically underwritten in nearly every state, making pre-existing conditions an obstacle to getting coverage. In addition, the level of coverage was traditionally less than what group plans offered (for example, most group plans covered maternity, while individual plans typically excluded this benefit before the ACA mandated it).
All of this changed in 2014 though, when the bulk of the ACA’s reforms took effect. Individual plans became more benefit-rich with the introduction of the ACA’s essential health benefits, and also became guaranteed issue, meaning that eligibility is no longer based on medical history and applicants no longer face higher premiums or rejected applications due to a pre-existing condition (but the trade-off is that enrollment is now limited to one annual open enrollment period and special enrollment periods triggered by qualifying events).
As a result, full-price premiums for individual health insurance are now nearly as high as the premiums for employer-sponsored coverage: The average full premium (pre-subsidy) for individual health insurance purchased through the marketplaces/exchanges in 2020 was about $6,900 for the year for a single individual, while the average premium for an employer-sponsored plan was $7,470.
But there are still some differences. For example, PPOs and broad provider networks are much more common among employer-sponsored plans, while individual plans are much more likely to be HMOs or EPOs and to have fairly narrow networks and localized service areas (this is often true even for plans offered by the same insurance company in the same area, with different networks for the insurer’s individual plans versus their employer-sponsored plans).
Another important difference is that average deductibles do tend to be higher for the individual market plans that people select. In 2020, the average deductible on an employer-sponsored medical coverage plan was $1,644 in 2020, while it was considerably higher than that on the plans that people selected in the marketplace/exchange in most states (lower deductible options are available in most areas, but consumers who are buying their own coverage tend to be fairly price sensitive, making the very robust — but expensive — plans less popular overall).
Where can consumers buy individual health insurance coverage?
Individual health insurance is available via the exchange/marketplace in every state (Select your state on this map to see more information about your state’s marketplace). There are 36 states that use HealthCare.gov as their marketplace in 2021, while DC and the other 14 states run their own exchange platforms (Covered California, MNsure, Connect for Health Colorado, etc.).
Individual health insurance is also available outside the marketplace (ie, “off-exchange“) nationwide, with the exception of the District of Columbia (in DC, individual health insurance can only be purchased through the marketplace). But premium subsidies (premium tax credits) and cost-sharing reductions are only available if the plan is purchased through the marketplace.
In both cases — on-exchange or off-exchange — individual health insurance is only available during the annual open enrollment period or during a special enrollment period triggered by a qualifying event. In most states, the annual open enrollment period runs from November 1 to December 15, with coverage effective January 1. But the majority of the states that run their own exchange platforms tend to offer extended enrollment periods, some of which continue well into January.
Plan availability and coverage options vary considerably from one area to another. Some parts of the country have only a single insurer that sells individual health insurance, while other areas have several different insurers and dozens of healthcare plans from which to choose.
Regardless of whether you want to purchase your plan on-exchange or off-exchange, you can obtain personal assistance from an insurance broker in your area. And there are also navigators and enrollment counselors who can answer questions and provide information and assistance with on-exchange plan selections as well as Medicaid enrollment.
How much does individual health insurance cost?
The monthly premium payments for individual health insurance plans vary greatly, depending on the applicant’s age, zip code, whether they use tobacco, and the health insurance company they choose. But unlike policies issued in most states pre-2014, premiums do not vary based on gender or an applicant’s medical history.
Across the more than 10.5 million people who were enrolled in effectuated individual health insurance coverage through the marketplaces in 2020, the average premium was $575/month. But that’s the full-price premium, and most people don’t pay full price: 86 percent of marketplace enrollees were receiving premium tax credits (subsidies) in 2020, and those tax credits averaged $491/month. The federal government makes premium tax credit payments directly to the health insurers, covering the large majority of the average premium.
For comparison, the average full-price monthly premium for employer-sponsored coverage (for a single employee) was about $623 in 2020. But employers covered an average of $519/month of that cost, leaving the average employee to pay just $104/month out of their own pockets (payroll deducted, on a pre-tax basis).
Short-term health insurance plans are generally less costly than full-price individual health insurance. But for people who qualify for premium tax credits, an ACA-compliant individual health insurance plan can end up being less expensive than a short-term plan.
